Pung v. Isabella County: The Supreme Court Says the Tax Sale Price Sets What the Owner Gets
On June 23, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Pung v. Isabella County, No. 25-95. When a government forecloses on a home for unpaid property taxes and sells it, the former owner is owed the surplus: the auction price minus the tax debt. The owner is not owed the property's fair market value, at least when the sale is "fairly conducted in light of our country's history of tax sales." Three years after Tyler v. Hennepin County said the government cannot keep the surplus, Pung sets how much that surplus is.
Case: Pung, Personal Representative of the Estate of Pung v. Isabella County, Michigan, No. 25-95, 609 U.S. 30 (2026)
Argued: February 25, 2026 · Decided: June 23, 2026
Opinion: Justice Alito, for the Chief Justice and Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, Barrett and Jackson; Justice Thomas joined all but Part II-B
Separate opinions: Justice Sotomayor, concurring (joined by Gorsuch and Jackson); Justice Thomas, concurring in part and in the judgment (joined by Gorsuch except footnote 1)
Result: Sixth Circuit judgment vacated; case remanded
The facts: a $2,241.93 debt and a $76,008 sale
The Pung family's home was in Union Township, in Isabella County, Michigan. The case grew out of a dispute over Michigan's principal residence exemption. The family won twice before the state's tax tribunal and courts, but the county still treated them as owing $2,241.93 in property taxes. The family refused to pay, and the county foreclosed under the Michigan General Property Tax Act. That Act gave them a redemption period, required public notice of the sale, a court judgment of foreclosure and a sale to the highest bidder.
At the public auction, the home sold for $76,008. Its assessed value for tax purposes was $194,400. The county at first kept all of the money. About eighteen months later, the buyer resold the house for $195,000. Michael Pung, for the estate, sued in federal court. The District Court held that he was owed the surplus from the sale but not the property's market value, and the Sixth Circuit affirmed. Justice Thomas's opinion puts the surplus the county was ordered to return at $73,766.
Justice Thomas's opinion also tells the story differently from the majority. In his account, the family had paid every bill printed on their tax statements, the extra tax was added after the bill went out, and the Pungs said they did not receive the foreclosure notices in time. The majority did not resolve those disputes.
What the Court decided
1. Just compensation after a tax sale is measured by the sale price. The Takings Clause requires "just compensation" when government takes property. The Court held that after a tax sale, the baseline is the actual auction price, so the owner's compensation is the surplus. The Court gave three main reasons:
- History. For hundreds of years, English and American law allowed property to be seized and sold for taxes, as long as the government returned the surplus to the owner. Early federal tax statutes and the Court's own cases applied that rule.
- Owners can usually avoid the sale. An owner who gets proper notice and thinks the property is worth more than the debt can refinance, borrow against it, or sell it before foreclosure and keep the rest. The Court noted that the Pungs had years to do so.
- A market-value rule would make tax sales unworkable. The Court's own example: a house worth $100,000, a $20,000 tax debt, and a $60,000 auction price. Under the historical rule, the owner gets $40,000. Under Pung's rule, the government would owe $80,000, more than the sale brought in, and would lose $20,000 collecting a $20,000 debt.
The Court also said that eminent-domain cases, where market value is the usual measure, do not decide this question. Even in those cases the Court has refused to make market value the only measure of just compensation.
2. Returning only the surplus is not an excessive fine. Pung also argued that failing to pay market value was an excessive fine under the Eighth Amendment. The Court rejected that too: he offered no history or precedent showing that a fairly conducted tax sale is punishment, and the same practical problems would follow.
What the Court did not decide
The ruling is narrower than "the sale price is always enough." In his merits brief and at argument, Pung added new claims that the process itself was unfair. He argued the county took more than it needed when it could have seized money or placed a lien, and that it acted as a bailee of the property. The Court declined to rule on them because they fell outside the question it agreed to hear. It sent them back to the Sixth Circuit, which may decide whether they were properly preserved. That is why the judgment was vacated and remanded, even though the Court rejected the market-value theory.
The opinion records that both sides agree a jurisdiction might violate the Constitution with "blatantly unfair procedures," such as a sham sale or needlessly delaying a sale while prices crashed. They disagree on what a fair process is. The county says following state law is enough. The United States, as amicus, says sales must be fairly conducted in light of the nation's history and tradition of tax sales. Justice Sotomayor wrote separately to say she does not read the opinion as defining a fair auction or endorsing either test. Justice Thomas wrote that, in his preliminary view, what the county did to the Pungs was wrong and likely unconstitutional.
How Pung fits with Tyler v. Hennepin County
In Tyler v. Hennepin County, 598 U.S. 631 (2023), Minnesota law let Hennepin County keep everything a forfeited condominium sold for, including the $25,000 above the $15,000 debt. The Supreme Court held that the Takings Clause requires the government to return the surplus, the difference between the sale price and the debt. Pung takes that rule and answers the follow-up question: the surplus is measured from the price the sale actually brought, not from what the property might have sold for on the open market.
Read together, the two cases set a federal floor. A government that sells property for taxes must give back what the sale brought in above the debt (Tyler). It does not have to make up the gap between that price and market value (Pung), as long as the sale was fairly conducted. How the surplus is claimed, who is paid first and the deadline are still set by each state. Our guide to claiming tax sale overages covers that process, and the surplus funds by state hub has the rule in each state.
States can still require more
The Court was explicit that its job was not to decide whether tax sales are good policy. It noted that some states have chosen systems that try to get closer to market value, and said that it is one thing for a legislature to choose such a regime and another for the Court to impose one as constitutional law. Three examples from the statutes behind our state guides:
- Maine requires the municipality to list a foreclosed property with a licensed real estate broker and sell it at the highest price it can get (36 M.R.S. § 943-C). See our Maine guide.
- Massachusetts requires a holder that sells to list the property with a licensed broker, with an auction only after twelve months (G.L. c. 60, § 64A). See our Massachusetts guide.
- Oregon requires a former owner's primary residence in a residential zone to be listed with a broker, and other property to open at two-thirds of market value (HB 2089 (2025), § 6). See our Oregon guide.
In those states, what an owner gets back depends on the state statute, which can be more generous than the federal minimum Pung describes.
What changes for property owners
- The surplus is the federal entitlement. If your property was sold for taxes, the federal Constitution gives you the surplus from that sale. A claim that the government owes you the market value of the property, because the auction price was low, will not succeed under the Fifth or Eighth Amendment when the sale was fairly conducted.
- Claim the surplus, and claim it on time. That money is still yours, but every state sets its own claim form and deadline, and some are short. Check the official county surplus lists and the state guides.
- The cheapest protection comes before the sale. The Court's reasoning leans on the fact that an owner with notice can refinance, borrow or sell before foreclosure and keep the equity. If you receive a delinquency or foreclosure notice and the property is worth far more than the debt, those options exist only until the sale.
- Unfair procedure is still an open question. The Court left room for claims that a particular sale was a sham or was needlessly delayed. Whether a given sale qualifies is a question for a lawyer, not for a guide.
What changes for tax sale investors
- Buying below market at a fair public sale is not in itself unconstitutional. The Court rejected the idea that the government must pay market value whenever the auction price is lower. The Court said a market-value rule might well make tax sales impractical. The National Tax Lien Association filed a brief urging the Court to affirm.
- The surplus is still not the buyer's. Your winning bid above the debt is the surplus, and after Tyler it goes to lienholders and the former owner. Pung does not change that.
- The sale process matters more now. The Court tied its rule to sales that are fairly conducted. Notice, how and when the sale was held, and whether the procedure was followed are what the remand and later cases will look at. Those are also the problems that can make a tax title hard to insure, covered in our guide to quiet title after a tax deed.
- Tax lien certificates are not the subject. The case is about a county that sold a home and kept the proceeds. The opinion does not discuss lien certificates, interest rates or redemption.
Michigan after Pung
The county in the case followed Michigan's own foreclosure procedure (Mich. Comp. Laws § 211.78m). Michigan already returns surplus to former owners through a claim on Form 5743, filed by July 1 after the foreclosure, a process the state built after its own Supreme Court's Rafaeli decision in 2020. The Pung majority mentions that case only to say that a concurrence in it, which read Michigan's constitution, does little to explain the federal Takings Clause. Our Michigan surplus proceeds guide walks through the Form 5743 claim and deadlines.
Frequently asked questions
What did the Supreme Court decide in Pung v. Isabella County?
On June 23, 2026 the Court held that, after a tax foreclosure sale, the Fifth Amendment requires the government to pay the former owner the surplus proceeds of the sale, meaning the sale price minus the tax debt, and not the property's fair market value, at least when the sale is fairly conducted in light of the country's history of tax sales. It also held that keeping only the tax debt is not an excessive fine under the Eighth Amendment.
Is Pung v. Isabella County the same as Tyler v. Hennepin County?
No. Tyler (2023) held that a government may not keep the surplus from a tax sale. Pung (2026) answers the next question: the owner is owed that surplus, measured by the actual sale price, and not the higher market value of the property.
Can a former owner still sue after a tax sale that sold for far below market value?
Not on the theory that the Constitution guarantees market value. The Court left open arguments that a particular sale was unfair, such as a sham sale or a sale needlessly delayed while prices crashed, and sent Pung's own procedural arguments back to the Sixth Circuit.
Does Pung change how I claim tax sale surplus?
No. The claim process, deadline and order of payment are still set by state law. Pung confirms that what you can claim under the federal Constitution is the surplus from the sale.
Does Pung affect tax lien certificate investors?
Not directly. The case is about a government that sold a home and kept the proceeds. It does not discuss lien certificates, interest rates or redemption.
Sources
- Pung v. Isabella County, No. 25-95, 609 U.S. 30 (June 23, 2026), preliminary print, Supreme Court of the United States
- Supreme Court docket, No. 25-95
- Tyler v. Hennepin County, No. 22-166, 598 U.S. 631 (May 25, 2023)
- 36 M.R.S. § 943-C (Maine); Mass. G.L. c. 60, § 64A; Oregon HB 2089 (2025), § 6; Mich. Comp. Laws § 211.78m, § 211.78t
This article explains a court decision for general information. It is not legal advice. If you are facing a tax foreclosure or think a sale of your property was unfair, talk to a licensed attorney in your state.